Cost Segregation in Buffalo, NY

New York's cash-flow secret — $220K median prices, 85% building ratios, and the same NY state tax deductions make Buffalo the cost seg efficiency champion of the Empire State.

Population
1.2M
Median Home
$220K
Rent (3BR)
$1,450
Property Tax
2.15%
Annual Job Growth
8K+
Ranking
Cash Flow Play
Overview

Value Props for Investors

Cash Flow King
Exceptional Price-to-Rent Ratio

$220K entry with $1,450/month rents delivers strong cash flow from day one. Build a multi-property portfolio at a fraction of coastal market prices.

Cost Seg Optimized
85% Building Value Ratio

Low land costs mean 82-88% of your purchase goes toward depreciable building value — maximizing the impact of every cost segregation dollar.

Stable Employment
Corporate & Institutional Anchors

M&T Bank HQ, University at Buffalo, and a growing healthcare sector provide recession-resistant employment and high-quality tenants.

Tax Strategy

Cost Segregation & Tax Rules in Buffalo, NY

Understanding how federal and New York state tax rules interact is critical to maximizing your cost segregation benefits in Buffalo.

Cost Seg Overview
State vs. Federal Rules
Tax Landscape
Typical Purchase
$220,000
Building Value
82%
18% land / 82% building
Cost Seg Range
22-35%
of building reclassified
Home Age
75 yrs
Built ~1949
What Gets Reclassified

A cost segregation study identifies building components that can be depreciated over 5, 7, or 15 years instead of the standard 27.5 or 39 years. In Buffalo, typical reclassification rates are 22-35% of building value.

Purchase Price Breakdown
Building 82%$180,400
Land 18%$39,600
Building Value Reallocation (with Cost Seg)
5-Year Property17%
$30,307
15-Year Property11%
$20,205
27.5 / 39-Year (Remaining)72%
$129,888

5 & 15-year components ($50,512 = 28% of building) are eligible for bonus depreciation in Year 1.

Overline Study Cost & ROI
Overline Study Cost
$499 - $2,000
Avg. ROI
10-40x

The math: A $220,000 property with 82% building value and 28% reclassification yields ~$18,689 in Year 1 federal tax savings at the 37% bracket — significantly more ROI than traditional studies costing $5,000-$10,000+.

Housing Stock Advantage

With a median build year of 1949, Buffalo's housing stock has identifiable components (HVAC, electrical, plumbing, landscaping) that are strong candidates for accelerated depreciation.

Partial — Addback Required
New York Bonus Depreciation Conformity

New York requires a full addback of federal bonus depreciation. The state allows depreciation under pre-2002 IRC rules, meaning NY taxpayers must use standard MACRS schedules (without bonus) at the state level.

What This Means for Buffalo Investors: Federal cost segregation benefits apply in full — 100% bonus depreciation on reclassified components. State-level deductions follow standard MACRS schedules, creating a timing difference but not a permanent loss. The high state tax rate (up to 10.9%) means deferred state savings are still very significant over time.

Federal vs. NY Depreciation Timeline
PeriodFederal TreatmentNY State Treatment
Year 1100% bonus depreciationStandard MACRS (no bonus) — ~15% of reclassified amount
Years 2+Standard MACRS schedulesContinued standard MACRS depreciation
Section 179 Expensing
State ConformityLimited

NY limits Section 179 to $250,000. Plan accordingly when combining with cost segregation strategies.

Key Takeaway

A $500K property with a $350K depreciable basis and 30% cost seg reclassification yields ~$38,850 in federal tax savings in Year 1. NY state savings of ~$1,700 begin in Year 1 and accumulate over the standard depreciation schedule.

Bottom Line

Federal savings are immediate and substantial. NY state savings follow standard MACRS schedules without bonus — deferred but not lost. Given NY's high state tax rates, the cumulative state benefit over the depreciation period is significant.

Local Property Tax
2.15%
Buffalo effective rate
Transfer Tax
$2 per $500 (0.4%) + mansion tax 1%+ above $1M
State Income Tax
10.9%
Progressive
Property Tax Details

Erie County rate of ~2.15% is high but offset by very low property values. Actual annual tax bills on a $220K home are ~$4,730.

Assessment Methodology
MethodMarket value (NYC uses assessed value ratios by property class)
Reassessment CycleAnnually
Assessment BodyNYC Dept. of Finance / County assessors outside NYC
Appeal WindowMarch 1 for Class 1; March 15 for Class 2-4 (NYC)
Appeal Success Likelihood
Very High
LowModerateGoodVery High

NYC's complex 4-class system frequently over-assesses income-producing properties. Tax Commission appeals are free to file and have high success rates. Outside NYC, county-level SCAR (Small Claims Assessment Review) provides a simple, no-cost appeal process. High effective rates make successful appeals extremely valuable.

Work with Overline — Our team helps Buffalo investors identify over-assessed properties and file tax appeals. A successful appeal can save thousands annually and compounds your cost seg savings.

Illustrative Example

Cost Seg Example for Buffalo, NY

This example assumes a purchase eligible for 100% bonus depreciation. All factors below are based on averages from our historical cost segregation studies for NY properties. To see your exact savings, run a property-specific cost seg analysis below.

Typical Buffalo, NY Property Details
$
50%95%
5%35%
2%25%
Total Reclassified28% of building
10%37%
Estimated Year 1 Tax Savings
Building Value$180,400
$220,000 x 82%
Normal Annual Depreciation$6,560
$180,400 ÷ 27.5 yr (residential)
5-Year Reclassified$30,668
15-Year Reclassified$19,844
Total Accelerated$50,512
28% of $180,400 building value
Federal Tax Savings (Year 1)$18,689
$50,512 x 37% bracket
NY State Tax Savings (Year 1)$826
Total Year 1 Tax Savings$19,515
7.7x normal annual deduction captured in Year 1

NY State Tax: Federal cost segregation benefits apply in full — 100% bonus depreciation on reclassified components. State-level deductions follow standard MACRS schedules, creating a timing difference but not a permanent loss. The high state tax rate (up to 10.9%) means deferred state savings are still very significant over time.

Insurance & Risk

Insurance Landscape in Buffalo

Insurance costs directly impact your cash flow. Understanding Buffalo's risk profile helps you budget accurately and avoid coverage gaps.

Avg. Annual Premium
$1,600
Buffalo average
State Average
$2,100
9% below average (statewide) / 20-40% above in NYC
National Average
$2,300
for comparison
Key Risk Drivers
1
Heavy lake-effect snow
2
Ice dams and freeze damage
3
Severe thunderstorms
Coverage Recommendations
Flood insurance mandatory in FEMA flood zones (much of coastal NYC, Long Island)
Wind/hail coverage with separate deductible for coastal properties
Replacement cost coverage — critical for older brownstones and pre-war buildings
Umbrella liability ($1M+) especially for multi-family properties
Cost Seg + Insurance Connection

A cost segregation study documents building components and their values in detail — this supports accurate insurance replacement cost estimates. NYC property owners with cost seg studies are better positioned to substantiate claims and negotiate premiums on high-value properties.

Revenue Comparison

STR vs. Long-Term Rental in Buffalo

Compare short-term (Airbnb) and long-term rental income for a typical Buffalo investment property.

Long-Term Rental
Monthly Rent (3BR)$1,450
Annual Gross$17,400
Vacancy Rate6.1%
Net Annual$16,339
Tenant StabilityModerate — healthcare and university workers provide stable core tenant base
Depreciation Schedule27.5 years
Residential rental property
Tax TreatmentPassive Only
Losses can only offset passive income unless you qualify as a Real Estate Professional (750+ hrs/yr)
Short-Term Rental
Avg. Nightly Rate$130
Occupancy Rate55%
Annual Gross Revenue$26,100
Net Annual (after expenses)$17,800
Management20-25%
Depreciation Schedule39 years
Classified as commercial / transient use property
Tax TreatmentActive Income Eligible
Losses can offset W-2 / active income if you document 100+ hrs of material participation and meet IRS criteria
Cost Seg + STR Loophole

Buffalo's older housing stock and high building ratios make it one of the most cost-seg-efficient markets in NY. At $220K, the study cost ($3,500) delivers 558% ROI. The LTR strategy provides steady cash flow while cost seg supercharges your after-tax returns.

Market Fundamentals

Economy & Housing Demand in Buffalo

Strong economic engines create stable rental demand. Here is what drives Buffalo's economy and housing market.

Median Income
$42,000
Rent-to-Income
28%
Healthy ratio
Vacancy Rate
6.1%
Pop. Growth
+0.2% (stabilizing after decades of decline)
Major Employers
1
Kaleida Health (9K+)
2
M&T Bank HQ (7K+)
3
University at Buffalo (6K+)
4
Catholic Health (5K+)
5
Moog Inc. (3K+)
6
Rich Products HQ (2K+)
Top Industries
Healthcare
Banking & Finance
Education
Manufacturing
Life Sciences
Landlord & STR Rules
Landlord Friendliness
Moderate
Eviction Timeline
60-90 days
STR Regulation
Generally permitted

Buffalo allows STRs with a rental permit. Less restrictive than NYC. Growing tourism from Niagara Falls and Bills NFL games creates seasonal STR demand.

Why Invest Here

Buffalo is the quintessential cash-flow play — $220K entry prices with $1,450 rents create strong yield. M&T Bank HQ, University at Buffalo, and the growing healthcare sector provide stable tenants. The older housing stock (median 1949) means more renovated components eligible for accelerated depreciation. Buy 3 Buffalo properties for the cost of one in NYC and build a diversified cash-flow portfolio.

Where to Invest

Top Neighborhoods in Buffalo

#1
Elmwood Village
Walkable, vibrant neighborhood near Buffalo's cultural district
Price
$280K
Rent
$1,600
Yield
6.9%
Highest rents in Buffalo with strong tenant quality. Pre-war homes with renovated systems yield excellent cost seg returns.
$280K$1,6006.9%
Highest rents in Buffalo with strong tenant quality. Pre-war homes with renovated systems yield excellent cost seg returns.
Highest rents in Buffalo with strong tenant quality. Pre-war homes with renovated systems yield excellent cost seg returns.
#2
North Buffalo
Family-friendly area with parks and established infrastructure
Price
$230K
Rent
$1,450
Yield
7.6%
Balanced price-to-rent with stable demand. Older housing stock (1940s-1960s) with separate HVAC and plumbing systems.
$230K$1,4507.6%
Balanced price-to-rent with stable demand. Older housing stock (1940s-1960s) with separate HVAC and plumbing systems.
Balanced price-to-rent with stable demand. Older housing stock (1940s-1960s) with separate HVAC and plumbing systems.
#3
University Heights
Student-driven rental market near UB South Campus
Price
$160K
Rent
$1,200
Yield
9.0%
Lowest entry point with highest yield. Student housing demand is recession-proof. Multi-family conversions offer additional cost seg opportunities.
$160K$1,2009.0%
Lowest entry point with highest yield. Student housing demand is recession-proof. Multi-family conversions offer additional cost seg opportunities.
Lowest entry point with highest yield. Student housing demand is recession-proof. Multi-family conversions offer additional cost seg opportunities.
#4
South Buffalo
Working-class neighborhood with revitalization underway
Price
$180K
Rent
$1,300
Yield
8.7%
Affordable entry with improving fundamentals. Irish and blue-collar heritage creates strong community stability. Renovation creates additional depreciable components.
$180K$1,3008.7%
Affordable entry with improving fundamentals. Irish and blue-collar heritage creates strong community stability. Renovation creates additional depreciable components.
Affordable entry with improving fundamentals. Irish and blue-collar heritage creates strong community stability. Renovation creates additional depreciable components.
Local Partners

Investor-Friendly Partners in Buffalo, NY

We are building a curated directory of top investor-friendly brokers, property management companies, and service providers in Buffalo, NY.

Investor-Friendly Brokers

Top real estate agents who specialize in investment properties and understand cost segregation, 1031 exchanges, and cash-flow analysis.

Coming Soon
Property Management

Vetted property managers who handle tenant screening, maintenance, and rent collection for both long-term and short-term rentals.

Coming Soon
Insurance Agents

Independent insurance agents who specialize in rental property coverage and can leverage cost seg data for accurate replacement cost estimates.

Coming Soon

Are you a broker, property manager, or insurance agent serving investors in Buffalo, NY?

Partner With Overline
Frequently Asked Questions

Cost Segregation FAQ — Buffalo, NY

How much can I save with cost segregation in Buffalo, NY?

−

On a typical $220K property in Buffalo, cost segregation can yield approximately $19,515 in Year 1 combined federal and state tax savings at the 37% bracket, with a study ROI of 558%. Overline studies cost $499-$2,000.

What is the property tax rate in Buffalo?

+

The effective property tax rate in Buffalo is approximately 2.15%. Erie County rate of ~2.15% is high but offset by very low property values. Actual annual tax bills on a $220K home are ~$4,730.

Is Buffalo a good market for real estate investing?

+

Buffalo is the quintessential cash-flow play — $220K entry prices with $1,450 rents create strong yield. M&T Bank HQ, University at Buffalo, and the growing healthcare sector provide stable tenants. The older housing stock (median 1949) means more renovated components eligible for accelerated depreciation. Buy 3 Buffalo properties for the cost of one in NYC and build a diversified cash-flow portfolio.

What is the average insurance cost for rental properties in Buffalo?

+

The average annual homeowner insurance premium in Buffalo is approximately $1,600. Buffalo's insurance costs are below the state average. Lake-effect snow is the primary risk driver — ensure adequate coverage for snow load damage and frozen pipe bursts. No hurricane or coastal flood risk.

What are the STR and landlord rules in Buffalo?

+

Buffalo is rated "Moderate" for landlords. STR regulation: Generally permitted. Eviction timeline: 60-90 days. Buffalo allows STRs with a rental permit. Less restrictive than NYC. Growing tourism from Niagara Falls and Bills NFL games creates seasonal STR demand.

Who are the major employers in Buffalo?

+

Major employers in Buffalo include Kaleida Health (9K+), M&T Bank HQ (7K+), University at Buffalo (6K+), Catholic Health (5K+), Moog Inc. (3K+). Top industries: Healthcare, Banking & Finance, Education, Manufacturing, Life Sciences.

See Your Savings

Find Out How Much You Could Save in Buffalo, NY

Enter your property address to get an AI-powered cost segregation estimate in 60 seconds.