Why the Legal Foundation Matters
The question: How do you know a cost segregation study will hold up if the IRS audits you?
The answer: Court cases. Decades of them.
When the IRS challenges your cost segregation, they're checking whether your asset classifications match established legal precedent from Tax Court rulings.
This guide shows you:
- The foundational court cases that established cost segregation
- What the IRS accepts vs. challenges
- How to defend your positions
- Common audit triggers to avoid
Expert’s note (Sam Young, EA; Stanford MBA): I’ve led and reviewed 100+ cost segregation studies and defended classifications using Whiteco/HCA/AmeriSouth frameworks in audits. LinkedIn
Cost Segregation Basics (Quick Refresher)
What it is: Reclassifying building components to shorter depreciation schedules.
Normal treatment:
- Commercial buildings: 39 years
- Residential rentals: 27.5 years
With cost segregation:
- Personal property: 5-7 years
- Land improvements: 15 years
- Building structure: Still 39/27.5 years
The legal question: How do you determine what's "personal property" vs "building structure"? That's where court cases come in.
The 3 Most Important Court Cases
1. Whiteco Industries (1975) - The Foundation
What it established: The "Whiteco Factors" test that every cost segregation study still uses today.
The 4 factors:
- Can it be moved?
- Is it designed to be permanent?
- Does it have a specific useful life?
- How substantial is it?
Why it matters: This created the framework for deciding what's personal property (5-7 years) vs building structure (39 years).
2. AmeriSouth XXXII (2012) - Modern Application
What it established: Business function matters more than permanence.
Key rulings:
- Decorative/accent lighting = 5 years (serves branding, not building)
- Decorative finishes = 5 years (tenant-specific)
- Tenant-specific HVAC = 5-7 years
Why it matters: Even if something is "permanent," if it serves a specific business function rather than the building itself, it can qualify for faster depreciation.
3. Hospital Corporation of America (1997) - Business Function Test
What it established: Systems serving business operations (not building operations) = personal property.
Example: Medical equipment systems, nurse call systems, specialized electrical for equipment.
Why it matters: If the system serves your business equipment/function rather than just keeping the building running, it qualifies for accelerated depreciation.
Important Court Cases by Property Type
Restaurants & Retail
| Case | What Won 5-7 Year Treatment |
|---|---|
| Morrison, Inc. | Restaurant-specific electrical wiring |
| Shoney's South | Restaurant seating, decor, kitchen items |
| Albertson's | Grocery shelving and decorative finishes |
| Walgreen Co. | Retail fixtures and displays |
| Piggly Wiggly | Fixtures, counters, coolers |
Takeaway: Equipment-specific systems and removable fixtures qualify.
Manufacturing & Industrial
| Case | What Won 5-7 Year Treatment |
|---|---|
| Texas Instruments | Clean room systems, production electrical |
| PECO Foods | Refrigeration, processing equipment systems |
| Chief Industries | Conveyors, control systems |
| King Radio Corp. | Production-specific electrical |
Takeaway: Production equipment and process-specific systems qualify.
Office & Multifamily
| Case | What Won 5-7 Year Treatment |
|---|---|
| AmeriSouth XXXII | Decorative lighting, finishes, tenant-specific HVAC |
| Cole v. Commissioner | Interior partitions, wiring, cabinetry in leaseholds |
| Metro Nat'l Corp. | Tenant buildout components |
Takeaway: Tenant-specific improvements and decorative elements qualify.
Practical Classification Rules (Based on Case Law)
What Usually Qualifies for 5-7 Year Depreciation
Restaurants:
- Seating and booths
- Decorative lighting and finishes
- Kitchen equipment
- Bar equipment
- Restaurant-specific electrical/plumbing
Retail:
- Display fixtures and shelving
- Decorative finishes
- Point-of-sale equipment areas
- Specialty lighting
Manufacturing:
- Production equipment systems
- Process-specific electrical/plumbing
- Conveyors and material handling
- Clean room systems
Multifamily/Office:
- Decorative/accent lighting
- Removable partitions
- Tenant-specific improvements
- Fitness equipment areas
What Stays 27.5/39 Years (Building Structure)
- Foundation and structural frame
- Exterior walls and roof
- General building HVAC (whole-building systems)
- General electrical/plumbing (building-wide)
- Elevators and escalators
- Kitchen cabinets in residential (2025 IRS clarification!)
The 2025 IRS Crackdown: Kitchen Cabinets
CRITICAL WARNING: The IRS's 2025 Audit Techniques Guide specifically targets kitchen cabinet misclassification in residential properties.
The rule now: Kitchen cabinets in residential rentals = 27.5 years (building structure), NOT 5 years (personal property).
Why this matters: This used to be a gray area. Not anymore. The IRS is specifically looking for this in audits.
Exceptions (very narrow):
- Surface-mounted cabinets (not built into framing)
- Commercial tenant-specific installations (lab equipment, not kitchens)
Our recommendation: Unless you have extraordinary documentation, classify kitchen cabinets as building structure. The audit risk isn't worth it.
The Simple Classification Test
Is it Personal Property (5-7 years)?
Ask these questions:
- Can it be removed without damaging the building? (Yes = personal property)
- Does it serve specific equipment or business function? (Yes = personal property)
- Is it decorative/aesthetic rather than structural? (Yes = personal property)
If yes to one or more: Likely qualifies for accelerated depreciation
Is it Building Structure (27.5/39 years)?
Ask these questions:
- Is it structural or load-bearing? (Yes = building)
- Does removing it damage the building? (Yes = building)
- Does it serve the building as a whole? (Yes = building)
If yes to one or more: Probably stays at building depreciation rate
Critical Lesson: The Peco Foods Purchase Agreement Case
What happened: Company bought poultry facilities with purchase price allocations in the contract. Later tried to reallocate via cost segregation study.
Court ruling: You can't change purchase price allocations after the fact.
The lesson: Do cost segregation DURING the acquisition process, not just after. Purchase agreement allocations are generally permanent.
How to Make Your Cost Seg Audit-Proof
Required Documentation
✓ Professional engineering study (not a DIY spreadsheet)
✓ Site inspection and photos
✓ Component-by-component breakdown
✓ Citations to supporting court cases
✓ Adherence to Revenue Procedure 2019-33
Audit Red Flags to Avoid
❌ Kitchen cabinets classified as 5-year in residential (2025 IRS target!)
❌ Overly aggressive HVAC splits
❌ No engineering support
❌ Missing documentation
❌ DIY cost segregation studies
Safe Practices
✅ Use qualified engineering firms
✅ Conservative classifications on gray areas
✅ Extensive documentation
✅ Cite specific court cases
✅ Follow Rev. Proc. 2019-33 guidelines
Common Questions
Q: How do I know my cost segregation will survive an audit?
A: Use a qualified engineering firm that cites specific court cases for each classification, follows Revenue Procedure 2019-33, and provides detailed documentation. Avoid known audit targets like kitchen cabinets.
Q: Which court cases matter most?
A: The "Big Three": Whiteco Industries (established the framework), Hospital Corp of America (business function test), and AmeriSouth XXXII (modern application).
Q: Can I do cost seg on a building I bought 10 years ago?
A: Yes! File Form 3115 to change your accounting method. You'll catch up on all the depreciation you should have claimed.
Q: What's the IRS targeting in 2025?
A: Kitchen cabinet misclassification in residential properties is the #1 target per the 2025 Audit Techniques Guide.
Q: How important is the purchase agreement?
A: VERY. Per Peco Foods case, you generally can't change allocations retroactively. Plan cost seg BEFORE or DURING acquisition.
Your Action Plan
For CPAs:
- Use qualified cost seg specialists
- Cite specific court cases in your documentation
- Avoid kitchen cabinet issues in residential
- Follow Rev. Proc. 2019-33 religiously
- Maintain audit-ready documentation
For Property Owners:
- Only use professional engineering-based studies
- Ask your cost seg provider which court cases they cite
- Ensure they're aware of 2025 IRS kitchen cabinet guidance
- Keep all documentation for 7+ years
- Plan cost seg during acquisition when possible
Related Reading
- Cost Segregation Audit Risk: What Actually Triggers an IRS Audit — Practical guide to audit triggers and defense
- Cost Segregation for W-2 Earners — How high-income professionals use cost seg
- CPA Guide to Cost Segregation
- Partial Asset Disposition Guide
- 10 Depreciation Secrets
Sources
- IRS Publication 946 — How to Depreciate Property: https://www.irs.gov/publications/p946
- IRS Cost Segregation Audit Techniques Guide: https://www.irs.gov/businesses/cost-segregation-audit-techniques-guide
- Whiteco Industries, Inc. v. Commissioner (1975) — Whiteco factors
- Hospital Corporation of America v. Commissioner (1997) — business function
- AmeriSouth XXXII, Ltd. v. Commissioner (2012) — modern application
- Form 3115 instructions (method changes for depreciation): https://www.irs.gov/forms-pubs/about-form-3115
Disclaimer: This is educational content. Cost segregation requires professional implementation. Consult qualified tax and legal professionals.